1. Skip to content
  2. Skip to main menu
  3. Skip to more DW sites
Live TV
Latest audioLatest videos
In focus
Israel-Hamas warRussia's war in UkraineSouth Africa

Big Brother awards

October 17, 2009

An annual award for the greatest abusers of data protection and privacy infringement is highlighting those, considered by some, to be German privacy's public enemies. This is one award that no one wants to receive.

https://p.dw.com/p/K8v8
Big Brother Awards logo
Awards go to those who are considered to excel in the violation of privacyImage: AP

The Big Brother Awards 2009 wrapped up in Germany on Friday, handing out recognition to politicians and corporations with records of data and privacy infingement.

The big "winners" of Friday's Big Brother Awards were Germany's Family Minister Ursula von der Leyen and Interior Minister Wolfgang Schaeuble along with a slew of companies.

These so-called "Oscars for data leeches" have been awarded each year since 2000 by the FoeBuD association which was formed in 1987 for the Promotion of Mobile and Immobile Public Data Traffic.

Watching the watchmen

Called "Zensursula," or Censorsula, by the awards' organizers, Ursula von der Leyen won for her initiatives to block access to child pornography websites. This, according to the award's justification, created "a system for advanced content control on the internet, which could evolve into Orwellian proportions."

A sign reading "Democracy" (crossed out) and "1984"
The organizers warn of "Orwellian proportions" as in the famous novel "1984"Image: AP

However, the issue seemed moot as, the day before the awards ceremony, new measures were announced by the Christian Democrats and Free Liberal parties, that child pornography sites would be deleted at the source, rather than try to limit internet access.

Interior Minister Schaeuble's prize was one of recognition of lifetime achievement for his "obsessive ambition for turning the constitutional democracy into a preventatively authoritarian police-state," according to FoeBuD.

Rewarding the many, as well as the few

Also honored with an award was the International Association of Athletics Federations, which organized the World Championships in Berlin in August, for its invasively in-depth background checks on journalists in order to be permitted to cover the event.

Other awards went to German firms Lidl, KiK Textiles, HDI Gerling, Deutsche Bahn, Deutsche Post and Deutsche Telekom, as well as the farming company Claas GmbH, which was highlighted for placing a GPS tracking device in its combine harvesters to ensure no deviations were made by the vehicle during harvesting.

Upcoming Big Brother awards are in Zurich, Switzerland on 24 October and Vienna, Austria on 25 October.


sjt/dpa/EPD
Editor: Andreas Illmer

Skip next section Explore more

Explore more

Photo of a magnifying glass highlighting online data

Big Brother award shows data protection is still a nagging issue

Big Brother award shows data protection is still a nagging issue

Germany's policymakers have put reforms in place to better ensure data protection. But do they really hit the mark? (16.10.2009)
October 16, 2009
A magnifying glass over a computer screen

German Coalition Under Fire for Backing Online Investigation

German Coalition Under Fire for Backing Online Investigation

In an effort to enhance national security, Berlin has approved a new law allowing the Federal Criminal Police to secretly investigate personal computers. Critics warn the legislation is a violation of the constitution. (06.11.2008)
November 6, 2008

Poland Cracks Down On Liberal Media

Poland Cracks Down On Liberal Media

A group of Polish journalists are refusing to be screened by the government. They say authorities are using a recently passed vetting law to hit back against the liberal opposition and conduct a witch hunt in the media. (23.03.2007)
March 23, 2007